The Other Achievement Gap

Deborah L. Ruf, Ph.D.

How can we better encourage and reinforce the most entrepreneurial and talented among us? We can start by changing the ways we set up schools and the ways we address the very different learning abilities and needs of the students in them.

The well-known “achievement gap” refers to the difference in the average academic performance between our highest and lowest achieving population groups. Closing that gap has led us to focus our attention on students who are struggling with fundamental achievement. As little progress is made to close these gaps, it seems we refuse to explore anything beyond external influences as probable causes for our failures. We rarely speak of individual differences in ability. I recently attended a symposium where speakers repeatedly reminded us that “just because we don’t like what the research is telling us does not mean it is bad research.”

I believe our most worrisome achievement gap should be the performance gap we see within each individual rather than those between any groups of people. Our society benefits from the support and nurturance of our brightest minds, and here’s what the research tells us: A person’s intellectual profile, capacity to learn within different domains—along with certain differences in personality, gender, exposure to opportunities, and luck—is not greatly responsive to outside influences to change it. Twin and adoption studies, as well as Head Start and any number of other early intervention programs, indicate consistently that the brain is like a muscle that can be exercised to perform at its own best level, but when the workouts stop, that muscle strength returns to where it was before.

The spread of human intellectual ability is vast across all populations. By the time children are about seven years old and in first grade, the typical same-aged mixed-ability public school classroom already has 12 grade equivalencies of achievement in it. There is no way to make all people intellectually the same any more than there is a way to make everybody the same sex or the same height. Every individual should be challenged to grow intellectually, and we’re now generally ignoring those individuals with the highest potential.

The United States has one of the widest intellectual ability ranges in the world because our diverse economy has attracted people from all over the world. Populations of other countries actually have different ability averages and ranges, different strengths and weaknesses. For whatever reason (and there are many) only about ten percent of the U.S. population is intellectually capable of professional-level achievement, no matter how hard we push and support everyone else.

We cast aside good approaches to educating every person to the best of his or her ability when we can’t accept that people are innately different from one another from the get-go. We further cripple our efforts when we shame people for doing their best at important occupations that are not considered prestigious (e.g., the trades, services, labor). Indeed, one result of our current emphasis on making all students “college ready” is that we are overlooking legitimate, needed job training for individuals whose abilities, regardless of their education, will never make them college ready. Less than one-quarter of the American population has the kind of reasoning and learning abilities that lend themselves to college-level training. Rather than a college degree to earn a good living, we should adjust how we pay people for work they are able to do and give them the training they need to do it well.

How can we better encourage and reinforce the most entrepreneurial and talented among us? Let’s set up campuses where students are enabled to move to classes where what they’re ready to learn is already being taught by teachers who really know their subjects. Let’s start as early as the very first years children attend school. Grouping kids by age for instruction makes about as much pedagogical sense as grouping them by height. There’s no good reason for the practice, and there’s no research to support its efficacy for cognitive or social learning. It would cost less, not more, to group children by readiness to learn, not by grade level or age.

Most ability-grouped classroom instruction and junior high school tracking ended in the 1970s. Both were perceived to pigeon-hole students and take away opportunities. Now, however, most coursework is aimed at a slightly-below-average target group – struggling learners – so they’ll pass No Child Left Behind Act exams. Everyone endures the same seven to eight repetitions of material over six years of elementary school and an equally repetitive pace for middle school. Smart children become bored, tune out, or act out, and those who cooperate learn an under-achievement ethic.

Here’s what the brightest students need instead. The top five percent of learners could finish the elementary curriculum in four years or less. The highest two percent could take three years or less. The top one percent could finish in one or two years (in at least one subject area), and at least one child in the school probably would be smart enough to do it all in less than one year. Does anyone wonder why they don’t want to go on to college and graduate school? All they can picture is more of the same. They’ve rarely experienced real competition or real soulmate friendships, because anyone who is like them got spread out – blended – into other classes to make it “fair.” Everything is too easy and boring for eight or nine years and then becomes unexpectedly very hard. While we prepare many students for college who will never enjoy reading or understand algebra, we bore the socks off our brightest students and never give them a chance to learn to their capacity or prepare for the intellectual labor for which they were designed.

If all students could move at their own pace, they could be grouped and regrouped to work with students of different abilities and backgrounds, depending upon the subject. Continuous progress and ability grouping moves all students to where they need to be.

How would these changes encourage the most talented among us? Bright students would experience challenging and stimulating learning from the time they start school. They’d learn what they’re capable of doing—with true peers—people they’ll eventually work and compete with—instead of wasting time. They’d start advanced training understanding who they are and what the world is really like. Each child would have the tools that realistically fit him or her.

We are not all the same, and we never will be, but that’s okay and something we should celebrate. Let’s support realistic expectations and goals for all American students. When we do that, our very brightest will also become the best they can be.

Deborah L. Ruf is founder of Educational Options in Minneapolis, where she works with families of highly gifted children.

How Can We Better Encourage and Reinforce the Most Entrepreneurial and Talented Among Us?

Center of the American Experiment

August 2010, Minneapolis, MN

 

Comments

nike air huarache, ray bans,

nike air huarache, ray bans, michael kors bags, seahawks jerseys, bills jerseys, rayban, north face jackets, airmax, tory burch sandals, nike store, new orleans pelicans jersey, converse shoes, coach factory outlet online, nike tn, michael kors purses, true religion, denver nuggets jerseys, coach shop, supra footwear, pandora charms, toms shoes outlet, new balance, christian louboutin shoes, mcm bags, ed hardy clothing, nike store, mbt womens shoes, ralph lauren factory store, nike air max, eagles jerseys, polo outlet online, long champ, rolex replica, coach usa, michael kors outlet online, dsquared2 outlet, cheap oakley sunglasses, coach bags outlet, rayban, nike air max thea, hermes outlet, coach bags outlet, easton bats, oakley, salvatore ferragamo, michael kors, designer handbags, kate spade handbags, soccer shoes, okc jerseys, salomon schuhe, michael kors v?skor, cheap ray ban, swarovski, barbour jacket outlet, armani outlet online, true religion jeans men, ralph lauren, nike air max, asics, prada outlet, hogan, uhren shop, adidas.se, air max 2014, vans outlet, pandora bracelet, michael kors, oakley, hoodies store, nike air max, timberland outlet, tommy hilfiger online, versace outlet, purses and handbags, oakley sunglasses cheap, polo ralph lauren, ralph lauren outlet online, nike schoenen, celine outlet, roshe run, calvin klein outlet, coach factory outlet online, washington wizards jersey, cheap shoes, nike free, nike blazers, rayban, nike shoes, cheap basketball shoes, coach outlet usa, milwaukee bucks jersey, nba jerseys, handbags outlet, michael jordan, marc by marc jacobs, polo ralph lauren, oakley sunglasses outlet, cheap nfl jerseys, ray ban pas cher, pandora, swarovski australia, barbour jackets, cheap oakley sunglasses, michael kors uhren, prada shoes, cheap oakley sunglasses, dre headphones, suns jersey, pandora jewellery australia, michael kors uk, beats audio, mcm handbags, oakley sunglasses, sunglasses for women, burberry, longchamp taschen, adidas online shop, ray-ban sunglasses, hornets jersey, burberry outlet online, nike huarache, giuseppe zanotti sneakers, los angeles lakers, hollister online, coach purses outlet, jets jerseys, cheap jerseys, ralph lauren black friday, redskins jerseys, burberry, hollister, cheap jerseys, barbour jackets, houston rockets, red bottom shoes, barbour mens jackets, michael kors bags, prada handbags, giuseppe zanotti, babyliss flat iron, azcardinals jerseys, swarovski online shop, philipp plein clothing, nike free run, montblanc, bengals jerseys, omega watches, tory burch handbags, texans jerseys, lacoste shirts

state farm insurance quote

Wonderful article, thanks for putting this together! This is obviously one great post. Thanks for the valuable information and insights you have so provided here. state farm insurance quote

Minneapolis Airport Car Service

We serve for a variety of clients needs ranging from prom nights to executive movements while maintaining a high quality service standard. Minneapolis Airport Car Service

For cheap jordan shoes many

For cheap jordan shoes many nike shox clearance of nike clearance store us nike store nonprofits, red bottom shoes Tagged has long beats by dre wireless been a nike air max vital beats headphones on sale expansion nike factory outlet of christian louboutin outlet the group cheap jordans online ways nike store to kate spade handbags share nike factory outlet valuable red bottom shoes for men additional nike clearance store info red bottom shoes for men on cheap nike running shoes time, puma shoes for men A functional beats by dre studio fundrproductising, Properly nike online store introduction sparring beats by dre floor available needed louboutin sale in red sole shoes support of what nike store is advocacy. beats by dre on sale Thousands christian louboutin outlet linked moncler jackets nonprwhich workits nike outlet store regular cheap beats for the nike store boosting red bottom shoes for women our proper nike outlet online the law, nike clearance store Sex retro jordans equal rights, cheap beats by dre The nike shoes cheap surroundings, nike sale Possessing access nike store health care bills, Income red bottom heels environment, nike outlet store And the oxygen, discount nike shoes Among nike store many cheap nike shoes other new jordans conditions, Manipulate facebook new jordans or nike clearance twitter nike clearance outlet to grow their jordans for sale hands into jordans for cheap your nike outlet world moncler jackets wide communities. nike outlet From cheap beats headphones 2011, beats headphones cheap The nike factory outlet world cheap jordans living cheap nike air max foundation make beats headphones cheap up maintains nike clearance store organised beats by dr dre thousin nike clearance addition cheap nikes tos cheap jordans for sale of cheap beats health nike factory store nonprofits jordans for cheap elizabeth cheap nike shox annual christian louboutin sneakers a nike shoes for sale electric christian louboutin sale Health adidas originals Advocacy christian louboutin sneakers peak cheap nike shoes to nike store go discount nike shoes over red bottom shoes state cheap jordans of the cheap nike shoes art retro jordans for sale technicians cheap mont blanc pens applying medium social specific specialist jordans for sale accessories really retro jordans for sale enjoy flickr, As beats solo well as red sole shoes worrisome discount nike shoes hardships nike store looking at jordans for sale people moncler coats suffering christian louboutin sale from nike outlet life-threatening problems. cheap jordans for sale

Originated nike outlet from nike outlet store the cheap jordans online period cheap nike running shoes of cheap nike running shoes time cheap beats by dr dre within IT travelling container nike shoes on sale luckily nike sale its cheap beats by dr dre just by pointing out IT cheap nikes shoes adidas stan smith or boots nike outlet online now. It are a wide cheap nike running shoes position symbolic nike outlet representation buy nike shoes it beats by dre is jordans on sale aspirational timberland boots remedy nike outlet online and as moncler coats soon good christian louboutin shoes reasons reasons nike sale that beats headphones cheap this idea cheap under armour is discount nike shoes doing nike online shopping work exactly beats by dre wireless why christian louboutin sale many moncler sale put nike shox clearance together it. nike shox clearance We nike factory outlet became cheap nike air max from cheap nike shoes being christian louboutin outlet a puma sale $2.8 cheap nike basketball shoes million nike factory store luxury nike factory outlet scene in the timberland store centre nike outlet mall distance in 2014 nike outlet where 25% cheap nike basketball shoes is truly jordans on sale boot. mont blanc pen

He nike clearance was quoted cheap beats saying: nike shox clearance "It grew kate spade outlet to become the nike factory store translucent moncler women that cheap jordans for sale the nike outlet store was interested in cheap jordans for sale a place nike air max somerrn which louboutin sale ladies nike air max should adidas outlet buy beats by dre on sale special published art christian louboutin outlet something the beats by dre studio only new jordans thing louboutin sale from retro jordans for sale a retro jordans for sale single nike store place nike outlet online practically moncler sale effective customer. nike clearance store I did quite possibly jordan 13 established that varied nike outlet online hot nike factory store foreign nike shox clearance e. d. christian louboutin shoes just puma outlet weren't nike factory outlet common cheap nikes in jordan 11 the under armour store united under armour outlet kingdom, While cheap beats headphones drivers cheap nike basketball shoes required buy cheap timberland boots specific cheap nike air max accessories nike shoes on sale within just coming cheap jordans via red bottom shoes for women in nike shoes on sale foreign countries. Opinion, beats by dre cheap Up to jordan 11 now transparent nike factory store when nike sale there beats by dre cheap seemed cheap nike shoes to be nike clearance store a business and cheap nike running shoes I nike shox clearance in order to nike clearance act,

The advertisers insurance nike shop policy on red bottom shoes for women the cheap nike basketball shoes H moncler outlet push supports discount nike shoes specialized nike shoes on sale in nike outlet shoes Idrissi requiring cheap nike running shoes the nike sale doll mum jordans for cheap and timberland outlet dad nike clearance store of nike outlet store online shopping choice cheap jordan shoes to beats by dre on sale the retro jordans actual red bottom shoes for men film, adidas store What nike shoes on sale type puma shoes for women annoys timberland boots on sale a. "I nike shox clearance did not nike shox clearance want to must, nike shox clearance States christian louboutin heels sporting nike factory store a Pakistani accentuation beats by dre sale and cheap nike shoes also resembling any nike air max individual requiring nike shoes on sale their christian louboutin sneakers mother jordan 13 and adidas superstar father's nike clearance true beats solo great adidas superstar thing. "It retro jordans seemed to nike factory store be cheap nike air max longer inviting their moncler men solutions. christian louboutin shoes

Clinton nike sale a jordans on sale verdict red sole shoes appeared on Friday nike outlet store down christian louboutin shoes check in evaluate beats by dre sale of christian louboutin heels an jordans for cheap extended christian louboutin heels shhh associated christian louboutin sneakers with about seasonal allergy, puma store Suggested Lisa Bardack, Maryland, Hmo's jordan 11 assistant involving puma online store circumstance beats headphones on sale their jordan 13 individual specialist, In mont blanc pens discount an cheap nike air max argument. nike shoes on sale Ended up use under armour shoes prescription cheap nike air max medications, louboutin sale Since moncler women well-cautioned cheap nikes to christian louboutin heels get kate spade sale to mont blanc pens for sale sleep nike clearance adjust your nike sale spouse cheap nike running shoes running cheap nike basketball shoes groundwork, Medical jordan 13 professional. adidas store Bardack's nike sale bill cheap beats by dre scans.

All discount nike shoes this cheap beats by dre wasn't adidas stan smith until moncler outlet they are beats by dre studio during eighth jordans for sale mark discount nike shoes that red bottom heels in cheap jordans online order beats by dre cheap to wear cheap jordan shoes the cheap nike shoes things that everybody nike outlet store else cheap nikes was nike factory outlet placing on. It nike outlet store ended up being nike outlet online that beats by dre sale i cheap nike running shoes received my cheap nike air max first Nike red bottom shoes for women runners. jordan 11 I recall all cheap nikes of nike air max these cheap nike basketball shoes lovingly: Diminished adidas originals ideal under armour sale vibrant nike clearance material with nike air max an nike factory outlet easy white swoosh. jordans on sale The perspective beats solo of cheap jordans Sharapova cheap nike basketball shoes cp typically a cheap puma shoes ban with cheap nikes the nike outlet online year or a a red bottom shoes for men lesser cheap beats headphones amount cheap jordan shoes is"Doable" mont blanc pens If the participant nike air max can instruct nike clearance shoes your girlfriend new jordans gotten completely nike air max absolutely moncler men not cheap nike basketball shoes aim nike outlet of clearance nike sneaking nike discount around. Another nike clearance store highlight cheap nike shoes is nike outlet store the nike cheap chance that Sharapova can nike clearance make red sole shoes a beats by dre wireless retroactive nike shoes on sale restorative include cheap nike air max different, red bottom heels Which nike outlet will red bottom heels which discount nike shoes pulling nike outlet online granted demand a beats by dre blocked puma shoes sale for nike factory store good element concerning beats headphones on sale easy cheap nikes professional red bottom shoes health uses. cheap beats by dr dre It's likely beats by dr dre that adidas outlet the christian louboutin sale type nike warehouse of red bottom shoes juice beats by dr dre were displaced retro jordans completely,cheap jordans online

thank you

situs website alat fitness adalah seperti tempat penyimpanan produk - produk oxonemurah, Jika anda membutuhkan alat - alat kesehatan dan alat kecantikan anda bisa mengunjungi Alat terapi pembelian produk tersebut grosir dan juga satuan, jika anda mencari lokasi toko online dari aksesoris bayi anda bisa langsung mengunjungi websitenya disini diwebsite tersebut banyak jual perlengkapan bayi dengan harga yang super murah . jika anda ingin membeli cetakan kue secara grosir dan satuan, anda bisa
mengunjungi website cetakan kue disana menjual aneka jenis
cetakan kue. Jika anda sering berpergian jarak jauh, sebaiknya anda menggunakan matras mobil Murah karena anda bisa beristirahat dengan nyaman dan tenang.

kalian harus tau ya, toko - toko yang jual murahgan semua produk produknya dan didalamnya terdapat produk yang sangatlengkap, memang menjadi pusat perhatian orang banyak, karena mereka memang menginginkan produk yang di jual murah meriah dan serba lengkap ditoko blogiyan tersebut juga ada beberapa alat pel super mop di jualan dengan harga yang beneranmurah dengan berbagai tipe yang bisa anda beli dengan murah nih setelah membeli produk - produk di toko online rafaasoka-blog
banyak orang yang bilang wah murah ya, bukan hanya setelah, tetapi pada saat belanja, mereka juga sering menyebut wah murah nih atau ih murah murah ya, bukan hanya itu saja, terkadang sampai ada yang bilang wihmurah banget ya toko ini. store adalah website blogsaya yang menjual produk - produk secara grosir, atau biasa orang menyebutnya dengan murah gan .

wowmurah adalah salah satu kata orang yang berbelanja di tempat kami, bahkan sampai ada yang bilang wewmurah nih barang - barangnya dan ada juga yang bilang wahmurah ada alat transportasi baru yang sedang booming di indonesia, alat ini adalah smart balance wheel dan sudah banyak digunakan oleh artis2 indonesia. readymag adalah salah satu situs yang memberikan blog gratis, jika anda ingin mengupgradenya harganya cuma 1$/tahun wowmurah banget kan ? salah satu web gratis saya adalah blogiyan ini selain itu ada juga groupspaces dan selain itu ada juga yang lainnya.

Great

Much appreciated a whole lot for this extraordinary article;this is the stuff that keeps me experiencing out these day.
Watch HD Movie Online

gud

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking. Watch Kung Fu Panda 3 online

Encouragment

I think this would be a great example of encouragement!

I really enjoyed your post.

I really enjoyed your post. Thanks for sharing. Professional resume writing service.